| Pollution UpDate | |
| 1 Oct. 98 Joe Turner, Editor | |
| Pollution UpDate" is dedicated to the reporting of timely environmental news. I'd like to thank our readers for their comments and suggestions, and DEP for giving us plenty to write about. | Raymond Proffitt Foundation P.O. Box - 723 Langhorne, Pa. 19047-0723 gateway@rayproffitt.org http://www.rayproffitt.org |
RAYMOND PROFFITT FOUNDATION NEWS RELEASE
RPF SUES U.S. ARMY CORPS TO STOP VALLEY FILLS IN PENNSYLVANIA
On September 22, 1998, the Raymond Proffitt Foundation sued the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in Pittsburgh federal court. The Corps had approved Vesta Mining Company's permit to destroy over three acres of wetlands and two miles of stream so it may dispose of coal refuse. Vesta plans to create a valley fill in Scenery Hill, PA to handle over 30 million tons of coal refuse from a proposed longwall mine that will affect over 8,000 acres. The Foundation believes the permit was issued illegally because the Corps does not have authority to allow the conversion of waters of the United States into a waste disposal site. The Corps can only allow for the discharge of dredged or fill material to elevate the bottom of a wetland or stream. Typically, Corps permits are issued so that marinas or housing developments can be built---not landfills. Disposing of coal waste, even on a lined site, should require a pollution discharge permit issued by the state. While the state has issued a discharge permit to Vesta to discharge from the site, it has not issued a permit to discharge onto the site. The Foundation also alleges that the Corps cannot issue the permit because it would violate state water quality standards. Pennsylvania and federally imposed antidegradation water quality standards prohibit the destruction of streams. Other allegations are that the Corps failed to consider the effects of the overall project, which will affect other wetlands and streams; and that the proposed mitigation is inadequate. This is the fourth lawsuit the Foundation has filed opposing valley fills. The Foundation appealed the issuance of the Vesta permit (State Hearing Board), Pennsylvania's issuance of permits without Office of Surface Mining (OSM) approval (Pittsburgh federal court), and OSM's conditional approval of Pennsylvania's valley fill program (Harrisburg federal court). Joe Turner, a Director and Officer of the Foundation, says that "we fought for over four years to successfully make antidegradation the law in Pennsylvania, and valley fills violate that law. We will keep filing lawsuits until both state and federal governments decide to obey the law." For information, contact John Wilmer, Esq. (610) 565-2736 or jwilmer@ix.netcom.com <<<<END>>>>